Independence National Historical Park

INDE · Pennsylvania
PARTIALLY RESTORED, Court-Ordered FLAGGED FOR REVIEW
2 entries
35 photos
4 topics
Civil Rights & Racial Justice Civil War Slavery & Enslaved People Women's History

Park History

Sourced
Independence Hall, where the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution were signed
Independence Hall, where the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution were signed · Photo: NPS Photo · Public domain (U.S. Government work) · source ↗
The Liberty Bell, with Independence Hall behind it
The Liberty Bell, with Independence Hall behind it · Photo: NPS Photo · Public domain (U.S. Government work) · source ↗

Independence National Historical Park covers more than 51 acres of downtown Philadelphia, and at its center stands the old Pennsylvania State House, now Independence Hall. In its Assembly Room the Second Continental Congress adopted the Declaration of Independence on July 4, 1776; four days later the Declaration was read aloud to the public for the first time in the square outside. In 1787 fifty-five delegates were sent to Philadelphia, and in the same Assembly Room they created the Constitution — a document, the park’s own brochure says, that failed to adequately address slavery. Congress sat in nearby Congress Hall from 1790 to 1800, while Philadelphia was the nation’s capital, and the First Continental Congress had gathered at nearby Carpenters’ Hall in 1774. [1] [2]

The bell that hung in the State House steeple was first heard in 1753; its inscription reads “Proclaim Liberty throughout All the land unto All the Inhabitants Thereof.” In the 1830s anti-slavery groups named it the Liberty Bell; it cracked around 1846. The park’s brochure calls the crack a reminder that liberty is imperfect, hopefully evolving to include those denied full participation. [1] [2]

Congress created the park on June 28, 1948. The park was made by creating public parks and open green space around the founding-era landmarks, clearing later commercial buildings, drawing on the City Beautiful movement and the colonial revival of Williamsburg, and in the 1950s and 1960s park architects, archeologists and historians working on Independence Hall developed restoration methods the Park Service still treats as a model. Independence Hall was named a World Heritage Site in 1979. [2] [3] [1]

Women

Lucretia Mott and other activists of the Philadelphia Female Anti-Slavery Society wrote for The Liberty Bell, the Boston abolitionist annual that in 1839 first gave the bell its name in print and for twenty years used it as an anti-slavery symbol, John Paige’s special history study for the park records. On July 4, 1876, Susan B. Anthony gave the first public reading of a women’s declaration of rights here, urging suffrage. And on August 2, 1954, the General Federation of Women’s Clubs gave the Park Service $209,541.82 raised nationwide to restore and refurnish the first floor of Independence Hall — by the park’s account the largest single sum ever applied to the building to that time. [4] [2] [5]

Black history

Ona Judge hid among the free Black Philadelphians she had befriended — part of a city the brochure describes as home to people fleeing slavery and free people of African descent. The house itself was torn down in 1832, and for some fifty years after Independence Mall was built the site lay under a lawn and a women’s restroom, marked only by a small brass plaque. In 2002 independent scholar Edward Lawler Jr. showed that Washington had ordered a smokehouse on the lot altered as housing for his “stablepeople.” Lawler judged it most likely that the order was carried out and the building housed enslaved stable workers, and he pointed out that visitors would pass over that site on entering the new Liberty Bell Center; in the controversy that followed, attorney Michael Coard founded the Avenging the Ancestors Coalition, and on July 3, 2002, some five hundred mostly African American protesters demanded a memorial. The 2007 excavation uncovered the kitchen where Hercules cooked and drew more than 300,000 visitors in four months; the park then built its first community-based exhibit there, interpreting race and slavery. [3] [1] [2]

Slavery

Partly beneath today’s Liberty Bell Center stood the President’s House, the executive mansion of George Washington (1790–1797) and John Adams (1797–1800). The Washingtons brought nine enslaved Africans from Mount Vernon to work there at various times: Austin, Christopher Sheels, Giles, Hercules, Joe Richardson, Moll, Ona (Oney) Judge, Paris and Richmond. Under Pennsylvania’s Gradual Abolition Law of 1780, the park’s 2009 excavation report (revised 2023) explains, enslaved people became free after a six-month stay in the state, so Washington rotated them back to Virginia — a practice the report says itself violated Pennsylvania law, which was not enforced. In the spring of 1796 Ona Judge walked out while the family sat down to dinner and escaped to New Hampshire; she died free in 1848. Hercules, the chef, escaped from Mount Vernon on February 22, 1797. Adams, the brochure notes, never owned slaves. [3] [1]

Sources

  1. NPSHistory.com: Independence National Historical Park archive page — overview (from the 2018 NPS brochure) and establishment block
  2. Foundation Document, Independence National Historical Park (NPS, September 2017)
  3. Mooney, Levin, Wuebber, Jeppson, Roberts, LaRoche & Brauer, The Archeology of Freedom and Slavery: Excavations at the President’s House Site in Philadelphia (URS/NPS/City of Philadelphia, 2009; rev. 2023)
  4. Paige, The Liberty Bell of Independence National Historical Park: A Special History Study (NPS Denver Service Center, undated, c. 1985), ch. on the bell as an abolitionist symbol
  5. Lee & Anderson, The Role of the General Federation of Women’s Clubs in the Restoration and Refurnishing of Independence Hall 1953–1963 (NPS)
Flagged Entries (2)
Entry #439 PARTIALLY RESTORED, Court-Ordered

PARTIALLY RESTORED, Court-Ordered: 12 exhibit panels documenting slavery at the President's House

Fugitives From Justice - Wide
Life Under Slavery - Main
+13 more

On this very ground in Philadelphia stood the President's House — the executive mansion where George Washington lived while governing a nation founded on liberty. What the exhibit revealed, and what the administration removed, is that Washington brought nine enslaved people from Mount Vernon to work in this house: Oney Judge, Austin, Christopher Sheels, Giles, Hercules Posey, Joe Richardson, Moll, Paris, and Richmond.

Washington secretly rotated these individuals between Pennsylvania and Virginia every six months to exploit a loophole in Pennsylvania's 1780 Gradual Abolition Act, which would have freed any enslaved person who resided in the state for six continuous months. In 1796, Oney Judge escaped from this house and fled to New Hampshire. Washington pursued her for years but she was never recaptured. She lived as a free woman until her death in 1848.

In January 2025, the National Park Service physically dismantled the entire exhibit — all 30 individual signs and displays. After public outcry and a lawsuit by the City of Philadelphia (City of Philadelphia v. Doug Burgum), a federal judge — citing George Orwell's 1984 — ordered the panels restored. CBS News reported that during a court inspection, the 34 panels had not been destroyed, but certain panels "exhibited damage." The judge issued an order preventing any further removals or changes.

On February 19, 2026, 16 of the 30 signs were restored under the court order. Further restoration was paused on February 20, leaving 14 signs still removed — including panels on Chef Hercules, Oney Judge's escape, the Fugitive Slave Act, and three "History Lost and Found" panels documenting the archaeological discovery of the site. This remains the only known case where removed content has been partially returned.

Why this matters: The President's House exhibit was created after a 24-year campaign by Philadelphia's African American community to ensure that the story of slavery at the seat of presidential power would not be erased. Over 3 million people visit this site each year. Of 30 original signs, 16 have been restored and 14 remain removed.

Slavery & Enslaved People Women's History
Signs removed or changed (Save Our Signs tracker)
  • “The President's House Site” — restored
  • “The Executive Branch” — restored
  • “The Dirty Business of Slavery” — removed
  • “Life Under Slavery” — removed
  • “Chef Hercules” — removed
  • “Oney Escapes!” — removed
  • “I and My Household” — restored
  • “I am free now” — removed
  • “Refuge in the Country” — restored
  • “Death Carts” — restored
  • “I will fear no Evil” — restored
  • “Promoting the Abolition of Slavery” — restored
  • “Burn this treaty to Hell!” — restored
  • “We shall come to a civil war” — restored
  • “The Keeper of the House” — restored
  • “Mount Vernon to Philadelphia” — removed
  • “Washington's Death and a Renewed Hope for Freedom” — partially restored
  • “Contagion and Liberty” — removed
  • “The opener of the way” — removed
  • “A Day of Reciprocity” — removed
  • “Freedom might be too great a temptation” — restored
  • “Awarding a Peace Medal” — removed
  • “Strengthening Ties with the United States” — removed
  • “An Act respecting fugitives from Justice” — restored
  • “Suppressing the Opposition” — restored
  • “...is hereby empowered to seize such fugitives” — removed
  • “History Lost and Found: Making History” — removed
  • “History Lost and Found: Archeology” — removed
  • “History Lost and Found: Exposed, Contradictions, Discoveries” — removed
  • “The House and the People Who Worked and Lived In It” — restored
  • “Thomas Jefferson (1743-1826)” — removed
  • “[touchscreen at entrance to Independence Hall]” — removed
What the Park Service told the court (NPCA v. Department of the Interior, No. 1:26-cv-10877 (D. Mass.), Doc. 49-2 (June 17, 2026))
  • Portrait description; reason: Disparages Americans past or living; now: In the park
  • President's House Site exhibit panels (×34); reason: Disparages Americans past or living; now: Mixed glass panels restored; large format metal panels were damaged and not restored, pending active litigation
Exact Text Targeted for Removal
What the Administration Ordered Changed
Panel: “Life Under Slavery — Resistance”

The administration flagged this panel because it states President George Washington was “Concerned about his public image” when he had his steward, Frederick Kitt, sign a newspaper advertisement seeking the return of an escaped enslaved woman. The government questioned: “Do we know that Washington's motivation to have Kitt sign the advertisement was to uphold his reputation?”

Panel: “Life Under Slavery — Intentional Brutality”

The administration flagged this panel because it describes methods slaveholders used to “break the spirits” of those they held in slavery, including “whipping, depriving of food, clothing, and shelter; as well as beating, torturing, and raping those they enslaved.”

Panel: “Life Under Slavery — Stolen”

The administration flagged this panel because it states that enslaved Africans were “brutally kidnapped and forcibly brought to America.”

Illustration: “An Act Respecting Fugitives From Justice”

The administration flagged this artwork because it depicts “Washington's hands in the foreground; one with the Fugitive Slave Act, the other with a quill signing the Act, in the background a posse of white men are depicted with clubs and guns shooting at four black men (one who has been shot in the head) presumably escaping from slavery.”

Panel: “History Lost and Found — Making History”

The administration flagged this panel because it uses words like “profoundly disturbing” to describe Washington transporting enslaved people, and calls the site's history both “admirable and deplorable.”

View on map →
Entry #442 FLAGGED FOR REVIEW

FLAGGED FOR REVIEW: Exhibit panels (1 items)

3. Reconstruction
5. Charleston Bell and Segregation
+4 more

On July 4, 1956, Independence National Historical Park was officially established in Philadelphia, protecting the birthplace of American democracy where the Declaration of Independence was signed in 1776.

Congress authorized the park in 1948 in response to local advocacy, and the National Park Service began administration in 1950. Independence Hall, Congress Hall, and the Liberty Bell are the centerpieces, symbolizing America's founding ideals. The park encompasses over 51 acres in downtown Philadelphia, transforming an aging commercial district into preserved historical spaces.

The park submitted Liberty Bell Center panels explaining how abolitionists adopted the bell and its inscription, “Proclaim Liberty Throughout All the Land Unto All the Inhabitants Thereof,” as a symbol and gave it the name “Liberty Bell.” The panels also mention George Washington holding enslaved people while serving as president in Philadelphia and, in the park’s description, call out the systemic and violent racism and sexism of the post-Reconstruction era. [NPS review record]

Elsewhere in the park, the President’s House exhibit was physically removed and then partly restored by federal court order; see the separate President’s House entry. [NPS review record]

Why this matters: The bell got its name from people fighting slavery, and the panels flagged here say so. The park’s own brochure notes that the Constitution drafted in Independence Hall failed to adequately address slavery. Telling visitors who named the Liberty Bell, and why, is part of telling the founding honestly. [NPSHistory.com] [NPSHistory.com 2]

Slavery & Enslaved People Civil War Civil Rights & Racial Justice
Exact Text Targeted for Removal
What the Administration Ordered Changed

Please review the following panels in the Liberty Bell Center to confirm alignment with SO:

1. Exhibit panels

Two panels tell of how the Liberty Bell's Biblical inscription “Proclaim Liberty Throughout All the Land Unto All the Inhabitants Thereof,” a verse that in part refers to the freeing of slaves, motivated the abolitionist movement to adopt the Bell as a symbol for their cause and to give it the name “Liberty Bell.” Both panels give background to the growth and support of slavery in the US and the resistance to it, with violence on both sides. Also mentioned: George Washington holding slaves while serving as President of the US in Philadelphia and Independence Hall as a location where the Fugiti...

2.Exhibit panels

One section of panels cover the travels of the Bell during the Post-Reconstruction period in the United States. The section contrasts the use of the Liberty Bell as a symbol of universal freedom for the Abolitionist Movement prior to the Civil War. The introduction panel expresses how the same bell became a symbol of reunification after the Civil War as it made several trips around the nation beginning in 1885, including two trips south. It calls out the systemic and violent racism and sexism that existed in the US at that time. Another covers a visit to the Bell by the former President of th...

View on map →
Signs Documented by Save Our Signs
"The President's House Site" — before
"The President's House Site"
before
"The President's House Site" — after
"The President's House Site"
after
"The President's House Site" — restored
"The President's House Site"
restored
"The Executive Branch" (two panels that go together as one display) — before
"The Executive Branch" (two panels that go together as one display)
before
"The Executive Branch" (two panels that go together as one display) — after
"The Executive Branch" (two panels that go together as one display)
after
"The House and the People Who Worked and Lived In It" (two panels that go together as one display) — before
"The House and the People Who Worked and Lived In It" (two panels that go together as one display)
before
"The House and the People Who Worked and Lived In It" (two panels that go together as one display) — after
"The House and the People Who Worked and Lived In It" (two panels that go together as one display)
after
"The Dirty Business of Slavery" (two panels that go together as one display) — before
"The Dirty Business of Slavery" (two panels that go together as one display)
before
"The Dirty Business of Slavery" (two panels that go together as one display) — after
"The Dirty Business of Slavery" (two panels that go together as one display)
after
"Life Under Slavery" (two panels that go together as one display) — before
"Life Under Slavery" (two panels that go together as one display)
before
"Life Under Slavery" (two panels that go together as one display) — after
"Life Under Slavery" (two panels that go together as one display)
after
"Mount Vernon to Philadelphia" (plaque next to a TV monitor) — before
"Mount Vernon to Philadelphia" (plaque next to a TV monitor)
before
"Mount Vernon to Philadelphia" (plaque next to a TV monitor) — after
"Mount Vernon to Philadelphia" (plaque next to a TV monitor)
after
"Washington's Death and a Renewed Hope for Freedom" (plaque next to a TV monitor) — before
"Washington's Death and a Renewed Hope for Freedom" (plaque next to a TV monitor)
before
"Washington's Death and a Renewed Hope for Freedom" (plaque next to a TV monitor) — after
"Washington's Death and a Renewed Hope for Freedom" (plaque next to a TV monitor)
after
"Washington's Death and a Renewed Hope for Freedom" (plaque next to a TV monitor) — restored
"Washington's Death and a Renewed Hope for Freedom" (plaque next to a TV monitor)
restored
"Contagion and Liberty" (plaque next to a TV monitor) — before
"Contagion and Liberty" (plaque next to a TV monitor)
before
"Chef Hercules" (plaque next to a TV monitor) — before
"Chef Hercules" (plaque next to a TV monitor)
before
"Chef Hercules" (plaque next to a TV monitor) — restored
"Chef Hercules" (plaque next to a TV monitor)
restored
"Oney Escapes!" (plaque next to a TV monitor) — before
"Oney Escapes!" (plaque next to a TV monitor)
before
"Oney Escapes!" (plaque next to a TV monitor) — after
"Oney Escapes!" (plaque next to a TV monitor)
after
"I and My Household" — before
"I and My Household"
before
"I am free now" — before
"I am free now"
before
"I am free now" — after
"I am free now"
after
"The opener of the way" — before
"The opener of the way"
before
"The opener of the way" — after
"The opener of the way"
after
"A Day of Reciprocity" — before
"A Day of Reciprocity"
before
"A Day of Reciprocity" — after
"A Day of Reciprocity"
after
"A Day of Reciprocity" — restored
"A Day of Reciprocity"
restored
"Refuge in the Country" — before
"Refuge in the Country"
before
"Refuge in the Country" — after
"Refuge in the Country"
after
"Refuge in the Country" — restored
"Refuge in the Country"
restored
"Death Carts" — before
"Death Carts"
before
"Death Carts" — after
"Death Carts"
after
"...is hereby empowered to seize such fugitives" — before
"...is hereby empowered to seize such fugitives"
before
"...is hereby empowered to seize such fugitives" — restored
"...is hereby empowered to seize such fugitives"
restored
"Freedom might be too great a temptation" — before
"Freedom might be too great a temptation"
before
"Freedom might be too great a temptation" — restored
"Freedom might be too great a temptation"
restored
"Awarding a Peace Medal" — before
"Awarding a Peace Medal"
before
"I will fear no Evil" — before
"I will fear no Evil"
before
"I will fear no Evil" — after
"I will fear no Evil"
after
"Strengthening Ties with the United States" — before
"Strengthening Ties with the United States"
before
"Strengthening Ties with the United States" — restored
"Strengthening Ties with the United States"
restored
"Promoting the Abolition of Slavery" — before
"Promoting the Abolition of Slavery"
before
"Promoting the Abolition of Slavery" — after
"Promoting the Abolition of Slavery"
after
"Burn this treaty to Hell!" — before
"Burn this treaty to Hell!"
before
"Burn this treaty to Hell!" — restored
"Burn this treaty to Hell!"
restored
"We shall come to a civil war" — before
"We shall come to a civil war"
before
"We shall come to a civil war" — restored
"We shall come to a civil war"
restored
"An Act respecting fugitives from Justice" — before
"An Act respecting fugitives from Justice"
before
"An Act respecting fugitives from Justice" — restored
"An Act respecting fugitives from Justice"
restored
"Suppressing the Opposition" — before
"Suppressing the Opposition"
before
"Suppressing the Opposition" — restored
"Suppressing the Opposition"
restored
"The Keeper of the House" — before
"The Keeper of the House"
before
"The Keeper of the House" — after
"The Keeper of the House"
after
Thomas Jefferson (1743-1826) — before
Thomas Jefferson (1743-1826)
before
"History Lost and Found: Making History, Digging for History, Conflict and Collaboration" — before
"History Lost and Found: Making History, Digging for History, Conflict and Collaboration"
before
"History Lost and Found: Making History, Digging for History, Conflict and Collaboration" — after
"History Lost and Found: Making History, Digging for History, Conflict and Collaboration"
after
"History Lost and Found: Archeology" — before
"History Lost and Found: Archeology"
before
"History Lost and Found:  Exposed, Contradictions, Discoveries" — before
"History Lost and Found: Exposed, Contradictions, Discoveries"
before

Photos courtesy Save Our Signs (public domain)

Archive Photographs (14)

Photographs attached to this park's records in the leaked NPS review database.

A Gather Place - Anti-War PosterIH Kiosk WideIH Kiosk Close6. Franklin and Slavery - Antislavery letter3. Franklin and Slavery - Young Entrepreneur-Ad4. Franklin and Slavery - Freedom0. Franklin and Slavery - Scale7. Franklin and Slavery - 17872. Franklin and Slavery - Choices5. Franklin and Slavery - Education funding1. Franklin and Slavery - You DecideTJefferson PortraitTJefferson Portrait TextAdams Wayside
Related Lawsuit
City of Philadelphia v. Doug Burgum
Federal court ordered restoration of President's House signs on Feb 16, 2026. Signs restored Feb 19.
View court filing →
View court filing →
View court filing →

News Sources

Verified
📰
Philadelphia InquirerIndependence Park Trump Signage RemovalJan 22, 2026
📰
New York TimesLawsuit Over Slavery Exhibit Removed at President's HouseJan 23, 2026
📰
CBS News34 Panels at President's House: Court Finds Damage to Removed ExhibitsFeb 3, 2026
📰
Philadelphia InquirerTrump administration quietly removed mentions of slavery from Independence Hall, Thomas Jefferson portraitJun 29, 2026
📰
CBS News PhiladelphiaJudge orders Trump administration to safely store slavery exhibits removed from Philadelphia historical siteFeb 2, 2026

Share this page

Explore the Full Map

See all 446 entries across every national park and wildlife refuge.

Open Interactive Map →